I like this gal’s piece … my own notes … they in place of he will be used. I really believe most of this book was written to provide answers to people who were not given the respect and communication they deserve as human beings. Often time in order to get companionship or sex. No book will ever substitute for simply asking questions of the other person, rather than guessing.
I believe in the end this always come down to people openly and honestly stating their feelings and goals as they realize them. Not avoiding subjects or misleading people.
#1 – One reason they are not asking you out is he might be circling. Which is where they are getting to know who you are before ask to make the dating connection. Also, as the critique points out, sexism stero-type here that only the guys ask out. On the other hand, there is a very real reason for why this rule is around. Naturally, a guy or girl who is not with someone could be tempted to accept the attention of a lover. We were not made to be alone in life. More so for men. Men tend to say no less often to available sex than women. This casual relationship can be ok, if both people know from the get go, but most of the time that honesty is not the case and one person conceals their goal. Note, I am not pointing the finger at the person who just wants to have fun or sex, as often fun and sex are offered in the hopes of luring or tricking someone in to committing to another person – all the while stating they are ok with a casual relationship, when they are in fact not ok with it.
#5 – As someone who has absolutely loved another with all of his heart, I say that love is different from lust. Poly-amorous relationships are a good example, but they are defined by a set of clearly communicated set of expectations.
#7 – This is clearly about what someone expects. Talk to people out of their 20’s, who have had a marriage or two under their belt. The legal implications of this are pretty heavy. There are some very valid reasons to never marry.
#9 – People have varying levels of space. This comes down to did you ask how often they expect to communicate or see you when you went out the first few dates?
#10 – The core of the matter, not everyone lives the same way. If you are feeling left out or miserable enough that you picked up a book or blog for help … you need change. Either in the communication or in the person you are seeing. If you can negotiate enough of what you need & are happy – great! There is nothing wrong with open dating or relationships, as long as your expectations do not include forcing them to leave their current spouse to ride off into the sunset.
#11 – I am not sure about the title here, who would want a jerk/bully etc? Either way, the critique comes through solidly, saying people deserve more than a jerk to return their love. The idea of “…what you deserve…” leaves a bit of taste in my mouth, as working with battered women often shows that they do not feel they deserved any happiness. I wish the critique had explained her mother believed she deserved to be happy with a man who treated her well.
I always felt, there should be a part for “If he never has time for you…” in there, as often this comes up in cases of people on weird shifts, with kids from other relationships or commitments in general.
Over all, a good critique! The subject is one of those sad ones of unreturned feelings or returned in uneven amounts.
With all of my points listed now, the actual article link follows …
Before He’s Just Not That Into You was a corny movie with star-studded actors and actresses, it was a corny book that I am apparently unashamed to tell the world I own. No matter how much this book can be critiqued – and it can and has been, mercilessly – I still think some of it is just flat-out honest reality. And yes, maybe that reality is subjective, culturally and generationally specific, and all the rest. But I did read the book again recently, which is five years from when I initially bought it, and ten years from its original publishing date. So in honor of ten years of the book being if not culturally relevant, at least rhetorically influential, I thought I’d review the given advice:
1. “He’s just not that into you If he’s not asking you out.”
Like many other ladies, I was told…
View original post 1,273 more words